Tuff, tephra, tufa, travertine: what’s the difference?

Cliffs of white rhyolite tuff at Kashe-Katuwe Tent Rocks National Monument

Cliffs of white rhyolite tuff at Kashe-Katuwe Tent Rocks National Monument

Our visitors to Northern New Mexico aren’t here very long before they hear the “T” words tossed around. You arrange a visit to Bandelier National Monument and find yourself driving among the most unusual-colored cliffs you’ve ever seen:

On the drive to Bandelier National Monument

On the drive to Bandelier National Monument

When you get to the Monument the ranger tells you you’ve been driving through the Bandelier Tuff. Pretty soon you find yourself inside the stuff:

Exploring the cliff dwellings in Bandelier National Monument

Exploring the cliff dwellings in Bandelier National Monument

Or you make a road trip though the Valle Grande National Preserve, intending to stop at Los Ojos Saloon in Jemez Springs for one of their “Famous Jemez” Burgers, and get sidetracked looking at the Soda Dam right along the road outside of town:

The Soda Dam near Jemez Springs

The Soda Dam near Jemez Springs

This must be tufa, right? We just learned about tuff. Well, no, it’s technically travertine.

And why did they spray all that white concrete all over the rocks way out here?

The Guaje Pumice along the road to Los Alamos

The Guaje Pumice along the road to Los Alamos

Wait! The “High Desert Field Guide” I just bought says that’s a pumice deposit, and geologists call it tephra.

What a confusion of tongues! But as any student of the subject knows, the geological sciences are  afflicted by a kind of logorrhoea when it comes to naming things. The geologist P. D. Krynine called stratigraphy “the complete triumph of terminology over facts and common sense”. And that’s just stratigraphy.

Most people instinctively know that each of these words probably has something to do with volcanoes, somehow, and of course they’re right. Tephra refers to any of the fragmental material a volcano ejects, regardless of the size of the fragments. This includes primary material like ‘bombs’, ‘cinders’, and ‘ash” as well as blocks of rock torn from the volcano’s cone or carried up from crust. As long as this fragmental stuff lies loosely in cones or drifts or layers on the ground, it is still called tephra.

There have been eruptions of pumice – a sort of froth of natural volcanic glass – so recently in the Jemez Mountains that your can scoop up loose pumice out of the roadcuts with your hands:

A roadcut in tephra from the El Cajete crater in the Jemez Mountains

A roadcut in tephra from the El Cajete crater in the Jemez Mountains

Once this fragmental material consolidates into a more or less firm rock, it is called tuff. Some air-fall tephras are turned into rock – ‘lithified’ is the term geologists prefer, which means ‘turned into rock’ – by compaction and by ground water cementing the particles together. But most tuffs are formed almost immediately upon cooling, since the hot glassy fragments that make up the bulk of volcanic ash in pyroclastic flows are soft and hot enough to fuse together. This process is called welding. Depending upon the heat and size of the eruption and the proximity to the vent, a tuff can be welded weakly, or it can be fused together so firmly that you can scarcely distinguish it from lava.

Much of the Bandelier Tuff that visitors see on the way to Bandelier National Monument is only weakly welded, and once the weather-hardened rind is broken through, you can gouge out the tuff with simple tools. As you drive from Bandelier on into the Valles Caldera National Preserve, you might notice the tuff getting firmer and darker, breaking into hard plates of unmistakable rock.

A spectacular example of a welded tuff can be found within San Diego Canyon in the  Jemez Mountains at Battleship Rock:

The grim prow of Battleship Rock

The grim prow of Battleship Rock

The only way to gouge out these rocks is with a jackhammer. This body of tuff was laid down by a very hot pyroclastic flow that surged down a canyon cut in the flank of the Valles Caldera very recently, geologically-speaking. In fact it records a catastrophic phase in the eruption that put down the El Cajete pumice we saw earlier. The flow of ash and pumice was so hot that the fragments of pumice were deformed into squashed and drawn-out tongues of rock, called fiamme (Italian for flames):

Fiamme in the Battleship Rock Tuff

Fiamme in the Battleship Rock Tuff

Firmly welded tuffs deposited from hot pyroclastic flows of ash are sometimes called ignimbrites. You really can’t help loving this word: “glowing cloud stone”.

Travertine is calcium carbonate rock (“limestone”) deposited from a hot spring. Since the rock consolidates from material dissolved in hot water, rather than magma, it is technically a sedimentary rock. You can watch travertine forming right before your eyes at Soda Dam:

Travertine forming around one of the hot springs at Soda Dam

Travertine forming around one of the hot springs at Soda Dam

Heat generated from volcanic activity in the Jemez Mountains has set up a naturally circulating hydrothermal system that dissolves calcium carbonate from beds of limestone  below the mountains, and then redeposits it at the surface where the hot water leaks out. The springs fizz with bubbles of carbon dioxide as the water depressurizes – hence the name Soda Dam – and this abrupt change in chemistry precipitates out the lime. This process is probably assisted by the algae that thrives in the hot water, accounting for the crusty, porous, almost baklava-like texture of the rock:

Older travertine at Soda Dam

Older travertine at Soda Dam

The only difference between tufa and travertine is the minor caveat that travertine is deposited from hot springs and tufa is deposited from springs at ambient temperatures. The only place I’ve seen tufa forming in Northern New Mexico is near Tunnel Springs in the Sandia Mountains near Albuquerque, where mineral-charged water seeping out of limestone beds is forming  deposits of scaly lime, intimately mixed with sticks and leaf litter. Many “petrifying springs” are springs busy laying down tufa. Some of the cooler parts of Soda Dam mimic this, slowly fossilizing grass:

Tufa-like deposits at Soda Dam

Tufa-like deposits at Soda Dam

So there you have it.

This entry was posted in Nature&history and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Tuff, tephra, tufa, travertine: what’s the difference?

  1. Laurie McGrath says:

    I loved reading this. Those of us who live here often gradually pay less attention to the formations around us until someone puts forth an interesting portrait. And then we look again. Thanks for offering us this lesson in terminology and beauty.

  2. Janet duffy says:

    I loved reading this as well! Of course, I love almost anything having to do with Outspire- every association, no matter how minor, always results in learning,smiles and fun!

  3. Outspire says:

    Thanks Laurie and Janet! Also nice for us to know that someone is enjoying the information!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s